Medicare Advantage Plans New York 2025

Searching for the best Medicare Advantage plans for 2025? We cut through the clutter to bring you a curated list of the best medicare advantage plans New York 2025, detailed comparisons of cost-effective options, and insights into plans with zero monthly premiums.

Understand how to maximize benefits, manage costs, and select a plan that aligns with your healthcare needs. Dive into the specifics without any fluff and make an informed decision for your health coverage this year.


Key Takeaways

  • New York offers a diverse range of Medicare Advantage Plans with providers like Independent Health, CDPHP, and Humana rated highly for member satisfaction, comprehensive benefits including prescription drug coverage, and options for zero monthly premiums.


  • Medicare Advantage plans in New York come with an extensive suite of benefits such as vision, dental, and wellness programs, enhanced prescription drug coverage, and additional health and wellness extras to support a healthier lifestyle.


  • Choosing the right Medicare Advantage Plan involves considering personal healthcare needs, plan networks and providers, and pharmacy access, along with being aware of key enrollment dates and utilizing available resources for plan comparison and maximizing plan benefits.

Compare Medicare Plans

Find a plan to fit your needs


Speak with a licensed insurance agent

TTY 711

Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm ET

Navigating New York’s Top Medicare Advantage Plans for 2025


Medicare Advantage Plans New York 2025 Navigating New York's Top Medicare Advantage Plans for 2025


New York boasts an extensive variety of Medicare Advantage Plans, each offering distinct benefits and features.

Whether you’re seeking a plan with stellar star ratings, cost-effective options, or zero monthly premiums, the Empire State has got you covered.


Spotlight on Star-Rated Medicare Advantage Providers

The Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services (CMS) assesses all Medicare Advantage providers and assigns a star rating based on the quality of their service and member satisfaction.

In New York, the top-rated Medicare Advantage providers for the 2025 plan year are:

  • Independent Health: 5-star rating


  • CDPHP Medicare Advantage: 4.5-star rating



  • MVP Health Care: 4.5-star rating


These high-star ratings reflect a commitment to member satisfaction, making these providers strong contenders when choosing a Medicare Advantage plan in New York.


Comparing Cost-Effective Options

Regarding cost, New York’s Medicare Advantage plans provide an array of options. The average monthly premium for 2025 is $30.79, a slight increase from the previous year’s average of $26.15.

Premiums can range from $0 to over $200, depending largely on the additional benefits included in the plan such as dental and vision coverage.

For the year 2025, Medicare Advantage (Part C) plans have set an out-of-pocket maximum of $8,850 for approved services, though some plans may offer lower maximums.


Exploring Plans with Zero Monthly Premiums

Many New Yorkers find the zero monthly premium Medicare Advantage plans appealing. These plans balance the absence of a premium with other costs, such as higher copays, deductibles, and coinsurance.

This makes them an affordable alternative while managing the cost of provided services.

However, the availability of $0 premium plans is not uniform across all areas of New York. Therefore, it’s advisable to check local plan offerings to ensure you find the most suitable and cost-effective plan for your needs.


Essential Benefits of Medicare Advantage Plans


Medicare Advantage Plans New York 2025 Essential Benefits of Medicare Advantage Plans


Medicare Advantage plans offer a comprehensive suite of benefits, including Medicaid services and:

  • Vision and dental services


  • Wellness programs


  • Prescription drug coverage


  • Hospital and medical coverage


  • Preventive services


  • Special needs plans


These plans, offered by private insurance companies, provide comprehensive coverage for all your health needs.


Enhanced Prescription Drug Coverage

Many Medicare Advantage plans prominently feature prescription drug coverage, which often surpasses the standalone Medicare Part D coverage.

These MA-PDs offer comprehensive prescription drug coverage, including a wide range of medications. This is particularly beneficial for beneficiaries with chronic conditions who require regular medications.

The cost of these medications can be significantly reduced by choosing a plan with a suitable formulary. In New York, as of March 2023, over a million individuals were enrolled in integrated Medicare Advantage prescription drug coverage, highlighting the popularity of this feature.


Dental and Vision Coverage


Medicare Advantage Plans New York 2025 Dental and Vision Coverage


The inclusion of dental and vision coverage is another noteworthy benefit of Medicare Advantage plans.

Dental coverage can range from preventive services to comprehensive procedures, ensuring your oral health is well taken care of. Vision coverage is also a staple in nearly all Medicare Advantage plans, covering essential services like routine eye exams and extending to corrective eyewear allowances.

This comprehensive coverage, supported by the federal government, ensures that your health care needs are met beyond basic medical services.


Health and Wellness Extras

In addition to standard benefits, Medicare Advantage plans frequently provide a range of health and wellness extras. These extras can include:

  • Gym memberships


  • In-home support services


  • Caregiver support


  • Other services aimed at supporting the overall wellness and healthcare satisfaction of Medicare Advantage members.


By utilizing these extras, you can pave the way to a healthier and more fulfilled life.

How to Select the Best Medicare Advantage Plan in New York

Selecting the appropriate Medicare Advantage plan demands thoughtful evaluation of various aspects.

A deeper understanding of your personal healthcare needs, the plan’s network and providers, and the drug formularies can guide your decision-making process.


Assessing Your Health Care Needs


Medicare Advantage Plans New York 2025 Assessing Your Health Care Needs


Choosing a fitting Medicare Advantage plan heavily depends on your individual healthcare requirements. Assessing your usage patterns, including the frequency of specialist visits, hospital stays, and routine check-ups, can help determine the level of coverage you need.

It’s also vital to anticipate any changes to your health care needs, such as upcoming procedures or the need to manage chronic conditions. This proactive approach ensures that the chosen plan will cater to your specific requirements.


Understanding Plan Networks and Providers

The network of providers is a pivotal aspect to consider when selecting a Medicare Advantage plan. Ensuring that your preferred healthcare providers and facilities are in-network can significantly reduce out-of-pocket costs.

It’s also worthwhile to understand the rules for seeing out-of-network providers and check if any necessary referrals for specialists are covered.

This comprehensive understanding of the plan’s network will allow you to make an informed and beneficial choice.


Considering Drug Formularies and Pharmacy Access

Considering drug formularies and pharmacy access is another critical aspect when deciding on a Medicare Advantage plan. These formularies can significantly influence out-of-pocket costs, so it’s crucial to ensure that the plan covers all your current prescription medications.

It’s also worth noting that formularies can change annually and throughout the year, necessitating regular reviews.

Additionally, convenient pharmacy options, like local or mail-order services, can greatly enhance the convenience and cost-effectiveness of your plan.

Compare plans & rates for 2025

Enter Zip Code



Enrollment Periods and Eligibility Criteria

Understanding enrollment periods and eligibility criteria is fundamental to the Medicare Advantage plan selection process.

Understanding these elements can ensure a smooth enrollment process and continuous coverage.


Key Dates for Enrollment

The Medicare Advantage plan enrollment process is governed by several key dates. The Initial Enrollment Period includes the three months before, the month of, and the three months after you first become eligible for Medicare.

If you missed signing up during your initial eligibility, the General Enrollment Period from January 1 to March 31 and the Fall Open Enrollment from October 15 to December 7 each year provide further opportunities to join a plan.

From January 1 through March 31 each year, the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period allows you to switch between Medicare Advantage Plans or revert to Original Medicare with or without Part D.


Preparing for Enrollment

Being well-prepared is vital for a smooth enrollment process in a Medicare Advantage plan. Resources such as, local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP), and licensed insurance agents can provide valuable information and guidance throughout the enrollment process.

In addition, understanding the costs associated with the Medicare Part B premium can aid in budgeting for your healthcare expenses.

Insights into New York’s Medicare Advantage Landscape


Medicare Advantage Plans New York 2025 Insights into New York's Medicare Advantage Landscape


The diversity of New York’s Medicare Advantage landscape mirrors that of the state.

With more than 3.8 million individuals enrolled in Medicare and nearly the same number covered by Medicare, understanding the landscape can provide valuable insights into your plan selection process.


Analyzing the Popularity of Plan Types

Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs), also known as health maintenance organization plans, and Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs), also known as preferred provider organization plans, Private Fee-For-Service (PFFS) plans, and Special Needs Plans (SNPs) are the most common types of Medicare Advantage plans in New York.

The popularity of these plan types has been increasing, with a 7.27% rise in enrollment between 2022 and 2023.

With 280 York Medicare Advantage plans offered in New York for the year 2025, the choice of the best Medicare Advantage plans can significantly influence your healthcare experience.


Regional Variations in Medicare Advantage Offerings

Your plan selection can be influenced by the regional variations in Medicare Advantage offerings. Some regions in New York offer broader networks or include out-of-network coverage, which is particularly beneficial for beneficiaries who travel or have providers outside standard plan networks.

Additionally, the costs associated with Medicare Advantage plans can vary based on the region of New York in which a beneficiary resides.

Understanding these regional variations can enable you to make a more informed and beneficial choice.


Resources for Medicare Advantage Plan Comparison

Although comparing different Medicare Advantage plans may seem complex, there are numerous resources available to simplify this task.

These resources include online comparison platforms and consultations with licensed insurance agents.


Leveraging Online Comparison Platforms

Useful tools to compare Medicare Advantage plans based on cost, coverage, and ratings are available on online comparison platforms like and

These platforms allow users to filter and sort plans according to their preferences, providing a user-friendly experience for plan comparison.

These tools can be particularly beneficial when comparing drug formularies and pharmacy access, ensuring that all your prescription needs are met.


Consulting with Licensed Insurance Agents

For personalized guidance in choosing an appropriate Medicare Advantage plan, consider consulting with a licensed insurance agent.

Platforms like and HealthMarkets connect beneficiaries with local agents who specialize in Medicare products.

These agents can provide expert advice and tailor plan options to your needs, ensuring that you make the most beneficial choice.

Maximizing Your Medicare Advantage Plan Benefits

Understanding how to effectively utilize the benefits of your Medicare Advantage plan is key to maximizing its potential.

This includes staying informed about plan changes and renewals, and utilizing preventive and emergency care appropriately.


Staying Informed on Plan Changes and Renewals

Ensuring continuous coverage of your prescription needs necessitates staying informed about changes in your Medicare Advantage plan’s formulary.

Formularies can change annually and throughout the year due to factors like new drug releases or shifts in clinical guidelines.

Plans are obligated to inform enrollees about any formulary changes at least 60 days in advance, providing ample time for beneficiaries to make necessary adjustments to their medication plans.


Utilizing Preventive and Emergency Care Appropriately

In addition to copayments for other hospital services, Medicare Advantage plans usually necessitate a copayment for each visit to the emergency department.

After meeting the Medicare Part B deductible, beneficiaries pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount for the doctor’s services during an emergency department visit.

However, copayments for an emergency department visit are waived if the beneficiary is admitted to the same hospital for a related condition within three days of the ER visit.

Understanding these specifics can help you utilize emergency care services appropriately and manage your healthcare expenses.



In conclusion, understanding the Medicare Advantage landscape in New York, evaluating personal healthcare needs, considering plan networks and providers, and leveraging resources for plan comparison can greatly simplify the process of choosing a Medicare Advantage plan.

By staying informed about plan changes and renewals and utilizing preventive and emergency care appropriately, you can maximize your Medicare Advantage plan benefits.

Compare plans & rates for 2025

Enter Zip Code



Frequently Asked Questions


What is the highest rated Medicare Advantage plan?

The highest rated Medicare Advantage plan is AARP/UnitedHealthcare, featuring high star ratings, a large provider network, and a broad array of options. UnitedHealthcare is the largest provider of Medicare Advantage plans.


Is Medicare premiums going down in 2025?

Medicare premiums are going up in 2025, with a monthly increase of $9.80 and higher costs for those with higher incomes. The standard monthly premium will be $174.70, up from $164.90 in 2023.


Why are people leaving Medicare Advantage plans?

People are leaving Medicare Advantage plans due to excessive prior authorization denial rates and slow payments from insurers. These issues have made the plans less attractive to many individuals.


What are the different types of Medicare Advantage plans available in New York?

In New York, the common types of Medicare Advantage plans are Health Maintenance Organizations (HMO), Preferred Provider Organizations (PPO), Private Fee-For-Service (PFFS) plans, and Special Needs Plans (SNP). It’s important to consider the specific coverage and costs of each plan before choosing one.


When can I enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan in New York?

You can enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan in New York during the Initial Enrollment Period, the General Enrollment Period from January 1 to March 31, or the Fall Open Enrollment from October 15 to December 7 each year.





call now

Compare Medicare Plans

Find a plan to fit your needs


Speak with a licensed insurance agent

TTY 711

Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm ET