Best Medicare Advantage Plans Pennsylvania 2025

Choosing the best Medicare Advantage plans in Pennsylvania for 2025 hinges on quality, affordability, and network adequacy. In this article, we focus on the best Medicare Advantage plans in Pennsylvania 2025, emphasizing CMS star ratings and tailored benefits.

We’ll break down the plans’ costs, benefits, and provider networks, giving you a straightforward comparison to pinpoint the coverage that’s right for you without the guesswork.


Key Takeaways

  • High-rated Medicare Advantage plans in Pennsylvania, identified by CMS star ratings, display a range of benefits including prescription drugs, dental, vision, hearing aids, fitness, and more, with prominent providers like Highmark and UnitedHealthcare offering 5-star plans.


  • Cost considerations when choosing Medicare Advantage plans are critical, with premiums, deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance varying, and the average monthly premium of $34.56 in Pennsylvania; tools like Medicare Plan Finder assist in evaluating these costs.


Compare Medicare Plans

Find a plan to fit your needs


Speak with a licensed insurance agent

TTY 711

Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm ET

Navigating 2025’s Top-Rated Medicare Advantage Plans in Pennsylvania

Medicare Advantage, a popular alternative to Original Medicare, offers Pennsylvania beneficiaries a wide array of choices, including many Medicare Advantage plans.


Why medicare advantage plans are bad



With each plan’s unique features and benefits, it can be a daunting task to choose the one that best fits your needs. But fret not! We’ve got your back. Our guide aims to help you navigate through the sea of Medicare Advantage plans, focusing on high-performance plans and their benefits.

Keep in mind that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) assess and award star ratings to Medicare Advantage plans. The star rating system, ranging from one star for poor performance to five stars for excellent performance, aids beneficiaries in selecting top-quality coverage.

So, the pursuit of high-rated plans is not just about obtaining premium services, but also about ensuring that you’re signing up for a plan that has been recognized for its outstanding performance.


Identifying High-Performance Plans

CMS star ratings serve as a compass, guiding beneficiaries towards high-performing Medicare Advantage plans.

These ratings are not just random numbers. They are derived from a combination of member input, plan-reported data, and outcomes across various measures of quality and performance. Hence, these ratings mirror the efficiency and effectiveness of the plans in real-world conditions.

Notably, providers like Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield and UnitedHealthcare have 5-star plans. And it’s not surprising that 74% of MA-PD enrollees in Pennsylvania are enrolled in plans with 4 or more stars.

Thus, during plan selection, the CMS star ratings and the high-performing icon on the Medicare Plan Finder can serve as reliable guides.


Understanding Plan Benefits and Extras

One of the compelling advantages of choosing a Medicare Advantage plan is the comprehensive Medicare Advantage coverage it offers, often beyond what Original Medicare provides. These plans include all Original Medicare benefits and often offer additional coverage, such as:


  • Prescription drugs
  • Dental and vision care
  • Hearing aids
  • Fitness benefits
  • Transportation benefits
  • Meal delivery


You might even find perks like transportation benefits or meal delivery added to some plans!

This extensive coverage can be a game-changer. For instance, routine coverage for vision, dental, and hearing care can be crucial for maintaining overall health.

However, it’s imperative to confirm that the additional benefits offered by a Medicare Advantage plan match your personal healthcare needs. After all, a benefit is only beneficial if it caters to your requirements, right?


Breakdown of Pennsylvania’s Premier Medicare Advantage Providers

Gaining insight into Pennsylvania’s Medicare Advantage providers is a key step towards selecting an appropriate plan. Leading providers such as:



Various insurance companies offer Medicare Advantage plans, each with unique features. For instance, Aetna Medicare Advantage is known for offering extra perks with their plans.


Best medicare supplement plans in pa



On the other hand, Blue Cross Blue Shield stands out for providing strong local support, a crucial aspect for beneficiaries who prefer community-based assistance.

If you’re on a budget, Humana Medicare Advantage is praised for its low-cost plan options, catering to those with fixed incomes. And if you value wide-ranging options, UnitedHealthcare’s extensive network size can be a significant advantage. Interestingly, Pennsylvania has seen an increase in Medicare Advantage plan availability, up from 262 in the previous year to 281 in 2025. So, you have a wide array of options to choose from!


Spotlight on Provider Networks

Provider networks are a critical factor to consider when choosing a Medicare Advantage plan. The types of healthcare provider options offered by these plans vary.

For instance, Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) plans require you to choose providers within a network. In contrast, Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) plans allow you to see any doctor or specialist, both in-network and out-of-network, without referrals.

On the other hand, the Private Fee-for-Service (PFFS) Plans provide flexibility by allowing you to choose healthcare providers without a primary care physician or referrals, as long as the provider accepts the plan’s payment terms.

Consequently, when choosing a Medicare Advantage plan, it’s critical to investigate the network size to guarantee access to preferred providers and confirm their inclusion in the plan’s network before enrollment.


Comparison of Prescription Drug Coverage

Prescription drug coverage is another critical factor to consider when comparing Medicare Advantage plans.

These prescription drug plans in Pennsylvania offer varying lists of covered drugs (formularies), necessitating beneficiaries to review the Medicare prescription drug coverage annually to ensure their medications remain covered and to understand potential cost changes.

The tier placement of drugs within a plan’s formulary directly influences the cost-effectiveness of a Medicare prescription drug plan, as plans often categorize drugs into several cost levels affecting affordability and access to medications. Some key points to consider are:


  • Review the plan’s formulary to ensure your medications are covered
  • Understand the cost levels and tiers of your medications
  • Consider the affordability and access to medications when comparing plans


Moreover, medication adherence metrics play a critical role in Medicare Advantage plan star ratings and should be considered by beneficiaries seeking comprehensive prescription coverage.

Beneficiaries can utilize tools to enter their prescription medications when comparing plans, allowing them to see clearly which Medicare Advantage plans cover their drugs and compare the associated costs directly.

Essential Guide to Cost Analysis of Medicare Advantage Plans

The cost is a significant factor when choosing a Medicare Advantage Plan. These costs can include:


  • Premiums
  • Deductibles
  • Copayments
  • Coinsurance


Some Medicare Advantage plans offer $0-premium options, but the average monthly premium for these plans in Pennsylvania is $34.56. For eligible beneficiaries, the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services offers Medicare Savings Programs, which can lead to savings exceeding $1,900 annually.

While the costs may sound overwhelming, it’s important to remember that these are not mere expenses, but investments in your health. Hence, comprehending these costs and their operation is key to making a knowledgeable decision about your Medicare Advantage plan.


Evaluating Monthly Premiums

Monthly premiums are a vital part of the cost structure of Medicare Advantage plans. In 2025, the average monthly premium for Medicare Advantage plans in Pennsylvania is $27.94, a decrease from the previous year’s average of $30.28.

Also, all Medicare-eligible individuals in Pennsylvania have the option to choose from several Medicare Advantage plans that have a $0 monthly premium.

While a $0 premium plan may sound appealing, it’s important to consider other aspects such as out-of-pocket maximums. For instance, plans like the HumanaChoice 120, with a monthly premium of $123, may offer lower out-of-pocket maximums like $6,700.

Therefore, while choosing a Medicare Advantage plan in Pennsylvania, it’s vital to consider not only the monthly premiums but also the potential out-of-pocket costs.


Deciphering Out-of-Pocket Costs

While premiums are a significant part of the cost, they are not the only expenses to consider. Out-of-pocket costs in Medicare Advantage plans typically include deductibles, copays for primary care and specialist visits, and coinsurance for services such as outpatient surgery.

Moreover, staying within a plan’s network is crucial since going out-of-network can lead to higher out-of-pocket costs or lack of coverage.

Out-of-pocket maximums also play a significant role. These serve as a cap on annual healthcare expenses. For example, plans like HumanaChoice set this limit up to $7,550. Choosing plans with lower out-of-pocket maximums can offer additional financial protection.

To aid beneficiaries in assessing plan premiums, deductibles, and estimated out-of-pocket costs, tools like the Medicare Plan Finder can be immensely helpful when used alongside the guidance of a licensed insurance agent.


Compare plans & rates for 2025

Enter Zip Code



Enrollment Insights: Timing and Eligibility for Pennsylvania’s Medicare Advantage Plans

Enrollment in a Medicare Advantage Plan is not an open-ended process. There are specific periods and eligibility requirements to keep in mind. In Pennsylvania, to be eligible for a Medicare Advantage Plan, individuals must be enrolled in both Medicare Part A and Part B.


Best medicare advantage plans for travelers



Beneficiaries with End-Stage Renal Disease (ESRD) or amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) are also able to enroll in Medicare Advantage Plans.

Interestingly, Pennsylvania residents under age 65 with a qualifying disability are eligible to enroll in Medicare Advantage.

There are also defined periods for signing up for a Medicare Advantage plan. These include the Initial Coverage Election Period, the Annual Election Period, and the Open Enrollment Period. Additionally, there are Special Enrollment Periods for specific life circumstances.


Key Enrollment Periods to Know

Understanding the enrollment periods is crucial for smooth enrollment in a Medicare Advantage Plan. The Initial Coverage Election Period starts three months before an individual’s 65th birthday, includes the month of, and continues for the three months following it. Alternatively, it correlates with the 25th month of receiving disability benefits.

There are several enrollment periods for Medicare Advantage plans:


  1. Annual Election Period (October 15 to December 7): Allows beneficiaries to make changes to their Medicare Advantage plans.
  2. Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (January 1 to March 31): Allows beneficiaries to modify their existing Medicare Advantage plans or revert to Original Medicare.
  3. Special Enrollment Periods: Additional times when eligible individuals can enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan outside the usual enrollment periods due to specific circumstances.


Compare medicare advantage plans



Who Qualifies for Medicare Advantage?

Qualifying for a Medicare Advantage Plan in Pennsylvania depends on certain eligibility criteria. Generally, individuals become eligible for Medicare Advantage when they:


  • Turn 65 years old, fulfilling the general age requirement for Medicare
  • Have certain disabilities
  • Have Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS)
  • Have end-stage renal disease (ESRD)


Moreover, Pennsylvania residents receiving at least 24 Social Security or Railroad Retirement Board (RRB) Disability Insurance payments can also qualify for Medicare Advantage before the age of 65.

Hence, comprehending these qualifications is vital as they can significantly impact your eligibility for Medicare Advantage plans.

Strategic Selection: How to Choose Your Ideal Medicare Advantage Plan in Pennsylvania

Choosing the ideal Medicare Advantage plan is not just about understanding the plans, providers, and costs. It’s also about aligning these with your unique healthcare needs and financial circumstances.

Thus, it involves careful consideration of your personal health care requirements, lifestyle factors, and whether the plan’s benefits match your specific needs.


Compare medicare advantage plans 2024



Moreover, it’s important to consider the possibility of personal health changes, the flexibility of the plan, and the impacts of costs and network limitations on access to care. This strategic selection process ensures that the plan you choose not only covers your current healthcare needs but also accommodates any future changes.


Assessing Your Health Care Needs

When choosing a Medicare Advantage plan, a one-size-fits-all approach simply doesn’t work. Your personal healthcare needs play a significant role in determining the plan that best suits you.

Any Medicare Advantage plan you consider should align with your personal healthcare needs, including coverage for any specific medical conditions or treatments you require.

Regular considerations for personal healthcare needs include chronic condition management, frequency of doctor visits, and anticipated surgeries or treatments.

Moreover, it’s important to check if a Medicare Advantage plan covers specific health services that you need, such as outpatient services, physical therapy, specialist care, or mental health services.


Balancing Cost and Coverage

Balancing cost with coverage is a critical aspect of choosing the right Medicare Advantage plan. Some options to consider are most Medicare Advantage plans, such as:


  • AARP/UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage Flex Plan 1
  • Aetna’s Medicare Value PPO
  • UPMC for Life Premier Rx
  • Highmark Complete Blue Signature PPO


These plans offer $0 monthly premium options, yet they demonstrate varying degrees of basic healthcare coverage without an additional monthly cost.

Comparing out-of-pocket maximums is also crucial in understanding the financial limits of a beneficiary’s annual healthcare spending. Medicare Advantage plans can offer added value through additional benefits such as dental, vision, and hearing care, which are not typically included in Original Medicare.

However, balancing cost with coverage must also consider potential downsides of Medicare Advantage plans, such as the need for provider networks, possible cost uncertainties, and the requirements for specialist referrals and authorizations.

Hence, it’s crucial to thoroughly assess both the plan’s cost and the benefits it provides to guarantee that your choice doesn’t compromise necessary healthcare services for affordability.


Comprehensive Resources for Medicare Advantage in Pennsylvania

As you navigate the Medicare Advantage landscape in Pennsylvania, access to comprehensive resources can be invaluable. These resources can help you understand the various plans, evaluate your options, and make informed decisions.


Highmark medicare advantage plans is the main online resource provided by CMS for Pennsylvania residents to learn about Medicare Advantage plans.

The types of Medicare Advantage plans and benefits available to Pennsylvania residents vary based on the insurance carrier and the beneficiary’s location within the state.


State-Specific Assistance and Counseling

State-specific assistance and counseling can be a boon for Medicare Advantage beneficiaries in Pennsylvania.

The Pennsylvania Medicare Education and Decision Insight program (PA MEDI) functions as the State Health Insurance Assistance Program. It provides free information and counseling on Medicare options. PA MEDI provides personalized assistance in:


  • Comparing Medicare Advantage (Part C) and Prescription Drug (Part D) plans
  • Medigap policy costs
  • Filing Medicare appeals
  • Understanding important documents such as the Annual Notice of Change and Evidence of Coverage.


PA MEDI reaches out to people across the state through health fairs, expos, and enrollment events organized at the county level. It also assists eligible individuals with Medicare Savings Programs applications, which can aid in covering costs related to Medicare Part A and Part B for those with limited income.

In addition, the Pennsylvania Area Agencies on Aging provide services and assistance to those over 60 and their caregivers, helping them to access various community services, which complements the supports offered by PA MEDI.


Online Tools for Plan Comparison

Online tools offer an easy and convenient way to compare Medicare Advantage plans. The Medicare Plan Finder on is an official resource that empowers Pennsylvania beneficiaries to compare various features of Medicare Advantage plans.

Beneficiaries can specifically compare prescription drug coverage, overall costs, and star ratings using the Medicare Plan Finder.

The tool offers the following features:


  • Personalization options, allowing users to input their medications and dosages to see their coverage under different plans
  • Filters to refine searches based on individual preferences
  • Information on specialized care options, such as the Program of All-inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE), can also be found through the Medicare Plan Finder.


Choosing a Medicare Advantage plan in Pennsylvania is a journey that involves understanding the various plans, assessing your healthcare needs, considering the costs, and making strategic choices.

With comprehensive resources and state-specific assistance, you can navigate this complex landscape with ease. Remember, the goal is not just to find a plan but to find a plan that best suits your unique needs and circumstances. Take control of your health by making an informed choice today!

Compare plans & rates for 2025

Enter Zip Code



Frequently Asked Questions


What is the most popular Medicare Advantage plan for 2025?

In 2025, Humana stands out as the most popular Medicare Advantage plan due to its high ratings, good benefits, and no-monthly-cost options in comparison to other providers like IBX.

AARP/UnitedHealthcare and Kaiser Permanente compared to companies such as Geisinger Gold are also reputable choices for their popular plans and exceptional customer service.


What is the highest rated Medicare Advantage plan?

The highest rated Medicare Advantage plan is the AARP/UnitedHealthcare plan, with high Medicare star ratings, the largest provider network, and a wide array of options. UnitedHealthcare (UHC) is the largest provider of Medicare Advantage plans.


Is Medicare premiums going down in 2025?

Medicare premiums are going up in 2025. The monthly Part B premium will increase to $174.70, an increase of nearly $10 a month.


Why are people leaving Medicare Advantage plans?

People are leaving Medicare Advantage plans due to excessive prior authorization denial rates and slow payments from insurers. These issues are commonly cited as reasons for the exodus.


What is a Medicare Advantage Plan?

A Medicare Advantage Plan is an alternative to Original Medicare, providing healthcare coverage from different providers.

Get Started Now

We can help make the process of finding the right Medicare Advantage plan easy.

To get started enter your zip code above to compare plans in your area, and even enroll online yourself!

Or, call us today to speak to one of our licensed insurance agents who can answer your questions and help find the best plan to fit your needs.

call now

Compare Medicare Plans

Find a plan to fit your needs


Speak with a licensed insurance agent

TTY 711

Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm ET